Revitalizing Busan: Lessons from ‘Triumph of the City

“The hallmark of declining cities is that they have too much housing and infrastructure relative to the strength of their economies” and emphasizes that "the folly of building-centric urban renewal reminds us that cities aren’t structures; cities are people.”

Maru Kim
Maru Kim

Busan, South Korea’s second-largest city, is at a crucial turning point. Known for its bustling port and rich cultural heritage, Busan is now grappling with significant economic and demographic challenges. Recent redevelopment efforts promise to transform the city into a global hub, but there are concerns that these initiatives may not address deeper economic issues. As Busan looks to its future, the lessons from Edward Glaeser’s “Triumph of the City” offer valuable insights into sustainable urban development.

Glaeser, an acclaimed urban economist, argues that cities are humanity’s greatest invention, driving innovation, economic growth, and cultural progress. His work underscores the importance of economic diversification, investment in human capital, and creating vibrant urban environments. These principles are particularly relevant for Busan as it navigates its path forward.

In this analysis, we will explore Busan’s historical and economic background, assess the effectiveness of current redevelopment strategies, and provide recommendations for achieving sustainable growth. By comparing Busan’s situation with the experiences of other cities, we aim to uncover strategies that can guide Busan toward a more resilient and prosperous future.

Formation and Decline of Old City Centers in Busan

Busan’s development as a major city in South Korea is deeply rooted in its strategic location and historical significance. Situated on the southeastern coast of the Korean Peninsula, Busan has long been a vital hub for maritime trade and industry. The city’s early growth was driven by its bustling port, which facilitated international trade and attracted a diverse population.

The post-Korean War period saw an influx of refugees who settled in Busan, particularly in districts such as Jung-gu, Seo-gu, Dong-gu, and Yeongdo-gu. These districts quickly developed into dense urban centers around the port. The rapid urbanization led to the construction of numerous residential and commercial buildings to accommodate the growing population. However, the infrastructure in these districts struggled to keep pace with the city’s expansion, resulting in a patchwork of outdated and inadequate facilities.

As global manufacturing and trade dynamics evolved, Busan’s reliance on traditional industries like shipbuilding and port logistics became a double-edged sword. While these industries initially spurred growth, they also made the city vulnerable to economic shifts. The relocation of major port functions to the more modern and efficient Busan New Port marked a significant turning point. This move left many older port facilities and the surrounding areas underutilized and contributed to economic stagnation in the original city centers.

Busan’s older districts, moreover, are now characterized by an aging population and declining birth rates. The younger demographic often migrates to the Greater Seoul area or abroad in search of better opportunities, exacerbating the demographic imbalance. This trend is particularly evident in areas like Yeongdo-gu, where the combination of an aging population and economic decline has led to numerous vacant properties and a lack of economic vitality.

The city’s efforts to pivot toward tourism and service industries have provided some economic relief, but these sectors predominantly offer low-wage jobs that do not fully compensate for the loss of higher-paying industrial employment. This economic shift has left Busan grappling with issues of income disparity and social welfare challenges, as the city needs to support an increasing number of elderly residents with a shrinking tax base.

In summary, Busan’s historical and economic background reveals a city that has thrived on its strategic advantages but is now facing significant challenges. The decline of traditional industries and the demographic shifts pose substantial obstacles to sustainable growth. Addressing these issues requires a multifaceted approach that goes beyond superficial redevelopment and focuses on creating a resilient and diversified economic base.

The Mirage of Modernization: Superficial Urban Redevelopment and Low-Wage Jobs

Glaeser states, “The hallmark of declining cities is that they have too much housing and infrastructure relative to the strength of their economies” and emphasizes that “the folly of building-centric urban renewal reminds us that cities aren’t structures; cities are people.”

Edward Glaeser in “Triumph of the City”

Busan’s current economic strategies and challenges highlight the complexities of revitalizing a city with a deeply entrenched industrial history. While there are ongoing efforts to modernize infrastructure and boost tourism, these initiatives must be scrutinized for their effectiveness in creating sustainable economic growth and addressing underlying issues.

Recent redevelopment projects in Busan, such as the North Port project, aim to transform the city’s landscape and attract tourists. The North Port redevelopment, for instance, includes plans to create an eco-friendly waterfront park, cultural districts, and commercial areas. While these projects can enhance the city’s visual appeal and offer new recreational spaces, they often fall short of fostering long-term economic stability.

Edward Glaeser, in “Triumph of the City,” warns against superficial urban improvements that do not tackle deeper economic issues. He argues that merely constructing new buildings and attractions can create an illusion of progress without addressing the fundamental need for economic diversification and high-value job creation. Glaeser states, “The hallmark of declining cities is that they have too much housing and infrastructure relative to the strength of their economies” and emphasizes that “the folly of building-centric urban renewal reminds us that cities aren’t structures; cities are people.” This critique is relevant to Busan’s current strategies, which risk becoming “hollow successes” if they do not go beyond aesthetics to create substantial economic opportunities.

Tourism has been a focal point of Busan’s economic strategy, with efforts to promote the city as a cultural and leisure destination. This includes developing attractions like the Busan International Film Festival and various coastal resorts. However, while tourism can provide an immediate boost to the local economy, it predominantly generates low-wage service jobs that do not offer long-term financial security for residents.

In districts like Yeongdo-gu, the reliance on tourism and the coffee industry to stimulate economic activity has proven insufficient. These industries do not provide the stable, high-paying jobs necessary to retain young talent and foster economic growth. Instead, they contribute to a cycle where the area remains dependent on a transient tourist economy, which does not address the structural issues of an aging population and economic stagnation.

The demographic challenge in Busan is stark, particularly in older districts where the population is aging rapidly. Young people continue to migrate to Seoul and other regions in search of better opportunities, leaving behind a growing elderly population that requires increased social services. This trend exacerbates the economic decline, as the city faces higher welfare costs with a shrinking tax base.

The impact of an aging population is evident in Yeongdo-gu, where many areas are dotted with vacant homes and underutilized spaces. The demographic shift not only strains social services but also limits the city’s economic potential, as there are fewer working-age individuals to drive innovation and growth.

Busan’s current economic strategies reveal a city at a crossroads. While redevelopment projects and tourism initiatives offer some benefits, they fall short of addressing the deeper economic challenges posed by an aging population and a lack of high-value industries. As Edward Glaeser emphasizes, sustainable urban development requires a focus on innovation, education, and economic diversification. Without these elements, Busan risks becoming a city with impressive infrastructure but limited economic resilience. The next section will explore insights from Glaeser’s work that can guide Busan towards more sustainable growth.

Superficial vs. Sustainable Urban Renewal

Edward Glaeser’s “Triumph of the City” provides a wealth of insights into what makes cities thrive and the pitfalls to avoid in urban development. These insights are particularly relevant for Busan as it navigates its current economic challenges and redevelopment efforts.

For a city to achieve sustainable growth, it must attract and nurture high-value industries that offer well-paying jobs. Glaeser emphasizes that cities thrive when they have a diverse economic base and are not overly reliant on a single industry. He notes that “industries are typically highly concentrated in a few cities. This ensures access to a skilled workforce, capital, and networks for exchanging ideas.” For Busan, this means moving beyond tourism and low-wage service jobs to attract sectors such as technology, finance, and advanced manufacturing.

One of the central themes of Glaeser’s work is the importance of human capital in driving urban success. He argues that cities must invest in education and create environments that attract and retain talented individuals. “To thrive, cities must attract smart people and enable them to work collaboratively. There is no such thing as a successful city without human capital.” For Busan, this involves enhancing local educational institutions, fostering partnerships with universities and tech companies, and creating pathways for continuous learning and skill development.

Glaeser provides numerous examples of cities that have successfully reinvented themselves by embracing innovation, diversity, and education. For instance, New York’s transformation from a manufacturing hub to a global center of finance, technology, and education demonstrates the power of economic diversification and strategic investment in human capital. Similarly, Boston’s emphasis on higher education and innovation has made it a thriving urban center.

In contrast, Glaeser highlights the decline of Detroit, which became overly dependent on the automobile industry. The city’s failure to diversify its economy and invest in education and innovation led to its decline. Glaeser writes, “Detroit’s twentieth-century growth brought hundreds of thousands of less-well-educated workers to vast factories, which became fortresses apart from the city and the world. While industrial diversity, entrepreneurship, and education lead to innovation, the Detroit model led to urban decline.”

Busan can learn from these examples by focusing on economic diversification and investing in human capital. The city should aim to attract a mix of industries and create a supportive environment for innovation and entrepreneurship. This could involve offering financial incentives, creating innovation hubs, and improving infrastructure to support high-tech industries. Additionally, investing in education and vocational training will help build a skilled workforce that can drive future growth.

By avoiding superficial improvements and focusing on economic diversification, high-value industries, and human capital, Busan can create a resilient and prosperous future. The next section will explore Busan’s current redevelopment efforts and how they can be aligned with these principles to ensure long-term success.

Current Redevelopment Efforts in Busan

Busan’s redevelopment efforts are ambitious, aiming to transform the city into a global hub through strategic infrastructure projects and special economic zones. These efforts are part of a broader vision to modernize Busan and boost its economic vitality. However, the success of these initiatives will depend on their ability to address deeper economic and demographic challenges.

The South Korean government has introduced the Global Hub City Special Act, designed to develop Busan into a key logistics, financial, and high-tech hub. This act aims to attract investments by designating special financial and logistics zones, providing financial and tax support to companies, and creating an autonomous education environment to attract top talent.

  • Special Financial and Logistics Zones: These zones are intended to enhance Busan’s role as a major logistics and financial center. By offering tax breaks and financial incentives, the government hopes to attract domestic and international companies.
  • Investment Promotion: The act promotes investment in high-tech industries, particularly in areas like future mobility, robotics, and artificial intelligence. The Centum 2 district, for example, is set to become an urban convergence special zone, integrating residential, commercial, and industrial spaces.
  • Educational Environment: Creating a self-regulating learning environment is crucial for attracting and retaining skilled professionals. This includes partnerships with universities and research institutions to foster innovation and continuous learning.

Several major infrastructure projects are underway in Busan, aimed at improving connectivity and enhancing the city’s appeal as a global hub.

Gadeokdo New Airport: Scheduled for completion by 2029, this new airport is expected to significantly enhance Busan’s connectivity with other major global cities. It is part of the broader strategy to position Busan as a central axis of South Korea’s southern region.

North Port Redevelopment: The North Port redevelopment project focuses on transforming the old port area into an eco-friendly waterfront park and commercial hub. The project includes the creation of waterside parks, cultural districts, and commercial areas, aiming to attract tourists and boost local economic activity. This project also involves significant infrastructure improvements, such as new roads and transportation links, to alleviate congestion and improve accessibility.

Centum 2 District: The Centum 2 district is an ambitious project aimed at creating a hub for high-tech industries. Spanning 1.91 million square meters, this district will integrate residential, commercial, and industrial spaces, fostering an environment conducive to innovation and economic growth.

Redevelopment of Aging Industrial Complexes

Western Busan Industrial Complexes: Busan’s western districts, including Saha-gu and Sasang-gu, house several aging industrial complexes such as Sinpyeong-Jangnim Industrial Complex and Sasang Industrial Complex. These areas are now facing significant challenges due to outdated infrastructure and economic obsolescence.

  • Economic Decline and Vacancy: Many companies in these complexes have struggled to compete with China, leading to high vacancy rates and a gradual shift of remaining businesses to newer industrial areas such as Gangseo-gu’s Shinho-Noksan, Saenggok-Mieum, and Jisa Industrial Complexes, or even to neighboring cities like Changwon, Gimhae, and Miryang. This has left large swathes of the industrial zones underutilized and in a state of decay.
  • Sasang Smart City Project: To address these challenges, Busan plans to redevelop the Sasang Industrial Complex into Sasang Smart City. This project includes the relocation of several administrative facilities, including Busan City Hall’s second office, to create a Western Busan Administrative Complex Town. The redevelopment aims to revitalize the area by introducing modern infrastructure and creating a mixed-use environment that integrates residential, commercial, and administrative functions.

Balancing Development Between Western and Eastern Busan: Saha-gu and Sasang-gu, both located along the Nakdonggang River, are key areas for industrial and logistical activities. The city’s strategy must ensure that redevelopment in these districts not only improves infrastructure but also attracts high-value industries and creates sustainable economic opportunities.

Redevelopment plans should focus on creating integrated urban environments that combine industrial, residential, and commercial spaces. This approach can help to revitalize these areas by making them more attractive to businesses and residents alike.

Improving transport links between these western districts and the rest of Busan is crucial. Enhanced connectivity can help to integrate these areas into the broader economic framework of the city and reduce the economic disparities between different parts of Busan.

Despite these ambitious plans, there are significant challenges that need to be addressed to ensure the success of Busan’s redevelopment efforts.

As Edward Glaeser warns, focusing too much on physical infrastructure without addressing underlying economic issues can lead to superficial improvements. There is a risk that these projects may not create the high-value jobs needed to sustain long-term economic growth.

While the focus on high-tech industries is a positive step, Busan must ensure that these industries are effectively integrated into the local economy. This involves not only attracting companies but also fostering local startups and small businesses that can drive innovation from within.

Creating an autonomous educational environment is crucial, but it requires significant investment and collaboration with top educational institutions. Developing a skilled workforce that can meet the demands of high-tech industries is essential for the success of these initiatives.

The aging population and outmigration of young people remain critical issues. Busan’s redevelopment efforts must include strategies to attract and retain young talent, such as affordable housing, vibrant cultural scenes, and ample career opportunities.

Busan’s current redevelopment efforts are ambitious and have the potential to transform the city into a global hub. However, to achieve sustainable success, these projects must go beyond superficial improvements and address the fundamental economic and demographic challenges facing the city. By focusing on economic diversification, investing in education and workforce development, and creating an environment that attracts and retains young talent, Busan can build a resilient and prosperous future.

Pathways to a Prosperous Future

For Busan to achieve long-term, sustainable growth, its redevelopment strategies must go beyond superficial improvements and focus on fostering a resilient economic base, enhancing human capital, and creating a vibrant urban environment. Drawing on insights from Edward Glaeser’s “Triumph of the City” and the experiences of other global cities, we can outline several key recommendations.

Busan needs to prioritize attracting high-value industries such as technology, finance, advanced manufacturing, and logistics. This can be achieved through a combination of tax incentives, grants, and supportive policies aimed at fostering a business-friendly environment. Establishing innovation hubs and business incubators is essential to support startups and small businesses. These hubs can provide resources such as funding, mentorship, and networking opportunities, helping to cultivate a dynamic ecosystem of innovation. Additionally, expanding the scope and effectiveness of special economic zones, as outlined in the Global Hub City Special Act, can attract domestic and international investments in high-tech sectors.

Investing in education is crucial for building a skilled workforce that can meet the demands of modern industries. Enhancing local educational institutions, including universities, vocational schools, and research institutions, is a key step. Forming partnerships with top global universities can enhance the quality of education and research in Busan, attracting talented students and faculty, and driving innovation and economic growth. Developing vocational training programs that align with the needs of high-value industries ensures that the local workforce is equipped with the necessary skills to thrive in a competitive job market.

Urban planning should focus on creating mixed-use developments that integrate residential, commercial, and industrial spaces. This approach can enhance livability, reduce commute times, and create vibrant communities. Investing in sustainable infrastructure projects, such as green public transport systems and eco-friendly buildings, can improve connectivity and reduce environmental impact. Ensuring the availability of affordable housing is essential to attract and retain young professionals and families, creating a balanced and diverse population.

Improving public services, such as healthcare, education, and transportation, is also crucial for making Busan an attractive place to live and work. High-quality public services can significantly enhance the quality of life for residents. Investing in healthcare facilities and services to cater to the needs of an aging population, including building new hospitals and clinics and improving existing ones, is necessary. Developing efficient and reliable public transport systems can improve mobility within the city and reduce traffic congestion.

Creating a vibrant urban environment with ample cultural and recreational amenities can attract and retain residents, especially young professionals. Developing cultural hubs and districts that offer a variety of entertainment, dining, and recreational options can become focal points for social and cultural activities, enhancing the city’s appeal. Investing in parks, gardens, and other green spaces provides residents with areas for relaxation and recreation, which are essential for improving urban livability and environmental quality.

Busan’s path to sustainable development requires a multifaceted approach that goes beyond cosmetic improvements. By focusing on economic diversification, investing in education and workforce development, implementing integrated urban planning, and fostering a vibrant urban environment, Busan can create a resilient and prosperous future. These recommendations, grounded in the insights from Edward Glaeser’s “Triumph of the City,” provide a comprehensive roadmap for the city’s transformation into a global hub that not only looks impressive but also thrives economically and socially.

Shaping Busan’s Future

Busan stands at a pivotal moment in its history. As South Korea’s second-largest city, it has the potential to become a thriving global hub, but it must navigate significant economic and demographic challenges to achieve this vision. By examining Busan’s current situation through the lens of Edward Glaeser’s “Triumph of the City,” we can gain valuable insights into the strategies needed for sustainable urban development.

Busan’s development has been shaped by its strategic location and industrial base. However, shifts in global manufacturing and trade have led to economic decline in traditional industrial sectors and older urban districts. The city faces challenges such as an aging population, declining birth rates, and economic stagnation in former industrial hubs.

Recent redevelopment efforts, such as the North Port project and the Global Hub City Special Act, aim to modernize Busan’s infrastructure and attract investment. However, these initiatives risk becoming superficial improvements if they do not address deeper economic issues. The city’s focus on tourism and low-wage service jobs provides short-term benefits but lacks the high-value job creation needed for long-term sustainability.

Edward Glaeser emphasizes the importance of economic diversification, investment in human capital, and creating vibrant urban environments. Successful cities attract and retain talented individuals, foster innovation, and ensure a diverse economic base. These principles are crucial for Busan’s sustainable growth.

Busan’s redevelopment plans, including major infrastructure projects and the redevelopment of aging industrial complexes in western districts, are ambitious. However, the success of these projects depends on their ability to create substantial economic opportunities and address demographic challenges. Strategies must include attracting high-value industries, improving education and workforce development, and enhancing public services.

Yeongdo-gu and western Busan exemplify the city’s broader challenges. These areas face economic decline, aging populations, and underutilized industrial complexes. Effective redevelopment in these districts requires a shift toward high-value industries, integrated urban planning, and investments in education and infrastructure.

To achieve sustainable development, Busan must focus on economic diversification, investing in human capital, integrated urban planning, and creating a vibrant urban environment. These recommendations, informed by Glaeser’s insights, provide a roadmap for transforming Busan into a resilient and prosperous global hub.

Policymakers, urban planners, and stakeholders must adopt a holistic approach to Busan’s redevelopment. This involves not only improving physical infrastructure but also fostering an environment that supports innovation, education, and high-value industries. By focusing on these key areas, Busan can create a sustainable and vibrant urban landscape that attracts and retains talent, drives economic growth, and enhances the quality of life for all its residents.

In conclusion, the lessons from “Triumph of the City” offer a valuable framework for guiding Busan’s redevelopment efforts. By applying these principles, Busan can overcome its current challenges and emerge as a model of sustainable urban development in the 21st century.

Share This Article
Leave a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *